[She might've been scared of him before - she might still be a little scared, honestly! - but... She can't be entirely scared of someone who looks so sad.]

I'm sorry. [She means it, too. Her tone is very genuine.] Doesn't that mean you can live a better life here? There's no one who wants you gone here, since if they did the magic wouldn't have gone through the trouble of bringing you in the first place. If the magic was just taking anyone it could reach, then there's surely a lot more people it could've chosen than just you or me or anyone who's been brought here.

[She's rambling, oh no. And saying things she shouldn't, probably.] Um. That's what I think, anyway. Y-You, um, you don't have to agree with me or anything.